Skip to content

Sport

Ignoring Biological Reality Puts Female Hockey Players at Risk

A frightening injury at an NHL-sponsored transgender tournament in Wisconsin reminds us why women’s leagues should remain sex-protected spaces.

· 12 min read
Ignoring Biological Reality Puts Female Hockey Players at Risk
Image by Jasper.

On November 22nd, the NHL made headlines when it tweeted that “Trans women are women. Trans men are men. Nonbinary identity is real.” Predictably, this declaration was widely praised by progressives and just as widely mocked by conservatives. And yet, amid all this culture-war sound and fury, there was little news to be had about the event that had precipitated the league’s controversial gender diktat in the first place: an NHL-supported and -sponsoredAll-Trans Draft Tournament” held in Middleton, WI—reportedly the first tournament of its kind in the history of hockey.

Aside from a tweet containing four photos of the November 19th–20th event, the NHL provided no substantive information about how the tournament unfolded. Nor did media outlets such as Hockey News, whose reporting consisted instead of cheery tournament summaries (“The arena was just buzzing with trans joy for two solid days”) sourced to the organizers’ social media accounts. Vice sent a five-person film crew to cover the tournament, including two cameramen, but so far hasn’t reported anything on what that unit filmed. So as far as I know, in fact, I’m the first person to publicly report the events described below.

The All-Trans Draft Tournament was organized under the auspices of Team Trans, a Massachusetts-based transgender hockey club that the NHL has been promoting and financing as part of its “Accelerating Diversity & Inclusion” mission. Last year, in a typically upbeat dispatch, NHL.com staff writer Amalie Benjamin reported that Team Trans allows trans hockey players “to be themselves. To open doors. To represent.”