Podcast
A #MeToo’d Scientist’s Courtroom Revenge
Podcast host Jonathan Kay speaks with ex-MIT molecular biologist David Sabatini, following his US$6-million legal victory over false accuser Kristin Knouse.
Welcome to the Quillette podcast. I’m Jonathan Kay.
And this week, I’ve got an episode that may give some of you a sense of déjà vu.
That’s because my guest is an acclaimed intellect who was falsely accused of sexual impropriety by an ex-girlfriend he met through work, got thrown out of his job as a result, and then turned the tables by suing his false accuser for defamation.
If you’re a regular Quillette podcast listener, that will sound familiar—since, just a few weeks ago, I spoke to National Post journalist Amy Hamm about her courtroom coverage of another blockbuster defamation trial—this one in Canada—which, by coincidence, happened to take place at roughly the same time.

That case involves former University of British Columbia creative-writing director Steven Galloway, the famed novelist best known internationally for his 2008 historically inspired work, The Cellist of Sarajevo.
As Amy informed listeners, Galloway had a consensual affair with a charming but deeply troubled middle-aged woman he met in his academic department—who then accused Galloway of rape years after their relationship ended. An investigation conducted by a former British Columbia Supreme Court judge determined the accusations were unsubstantiated, but the University of British Columbia fired Galloway anyway.

To this day, no one at the University of British Columbia has been held accountable for their role in this travesty of justice—except to such extent as Galloway himself was able to secure financial settlements after suing them for amplifying the original false accusations put forward by his aggrieved ex-girlfriend.

The story behind today’s guest, American molecular biologist David Sabatini, is eerily similar. In 2021, Dr. Sabatini was the subject of false accusations of sexual impropriety from his ex-girlfriend, a fellow researcher named Kristin Knouse. Dr. Sabatini was then forced out of his positions at both the Howard Hughes Medical Institute and the Whitehead Institute, which is affiliated with the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, where Dr. Sabatini was a tenured professor.
Like Galloway, Dr. Sabatini took his accuser to court. And on October 16, following a three-week civil trial in Boston, a jury awarded Dr. Sabatini $6-million in damages, a figure that may grow to almost $10-million once prejudgment interest is included.
As we’ll hear, the two cases are alike in another way: In regard to both Galloway and Dr. Sabatini, preserved copies of text messages exchanged with their respective ex-girlfriends have proven crucial in demonstrating the consensual nature of the underlying sexual relationships.
In a 2024 deposition, for instance, Dr. Knouse was asked by Dr. Sabatni’s lawyer about a text she’d sent describing her aggressive efforts to secure a late-night sexual liaison with him at a hotel the night before.
As we’ll hear, Dr. Knouse’s campaign to destroy Dr. Sabatni’s career through invented accusations—a campaign she called “Covert Operation Dethrone” in her text messages to others—didn’t just harm her intended victim. It also harmed the careers of dozens of other scientists who worked with Dr. Sabatni.
It also derailed many of their research projects, in some cases permanently—including efforts aimed at finding effective treatments for ovarian cancer, pulmonary fibrosis, ALS, and numerous other serious diseases.
Dr. Sabatini’s courtroom victory represents a major step toward clearing his name. But as you’ll hear, even this may not be enough to allow the star medical researcher to repair the damage caused by the lies peddled by Dr. Knouse and her “Operation Dethrone” enablers.
Quillette invites thoughtful responses to its essays.
Selected responses are published once per week as part of a curated Letters to the Editor feature. If selected, letters appear under the contributor’s real name and may be edited for clarity and length.
To submit a letter for consideration, please email [email protected].